Original listing
See the full details, photos and contact the seller on the original marketplace.
← BackFAIR BUY 
BMW X1
2017 · 100,000 km · Diesel · Automatic · Dublin
€17,950
🟡57/100FAIR PRICE€750 below comparable cars
Down €1,000 since listing
⚡
FAIR DEALQuick take
Why: €750 below comparable cars (4.0% under the fair value) · The seller has already cut the price by 5.3%
Suggested offer
€16,466
Max I'd pay
€17,705
🏆
My car buyer score
🟡
62/100
Fair — buy with checks
Swirl flaps / inlet manifold carbon build-up — typically from 150k km, about €900 to put right.
Deal score57/100
Is it cheap? Nothing special about the price.
Market value54/100
Is it below market? Asking about 4% under comparable cars.
Mechanical97/100
Is it mechanically a good buy? 1 known weak point for this engine and mileage · about €100 of likely repairs over 3 years
Reliability68/100
How much risk is there? Brand reliability index 68/100 with 1 documented weak point for this spec.
History65/100
Does the history look trustworthy? Everything obtainable here checks out. No open Irish history file exists, so a paid check is still worth it.
Running cost75/100
What will it cost to own? About €3,569 a year to run, excluding depreciation.
Resale42/100
What will it be worth later? Around €13,937 in three years.
Opportunity18/100
Is it worth buying now? Risk-adjusted read on acting now.
✓
AI buying verdict
On the evidence we hold, this is priced better than the comparable cars we can see.
Why?
- 4.0% below comparable cars
- 100,000 km on the clock
- Automatic transmission
- Price reduced by €1,000
- 6 comparable live listings used
- No data inconsistencies found
Confidence
84/100
Very high
Risk: Normal
€
What should you pay?
Asking price€17,950
Estimated fair value€18,700
Fair range€17,000 – €19,800
Recommended offer€16,466
Maximum we’d pay€17,705
Fair value is an estimated transaction value derived from live asking prices. It is not a verified transaction price.
▤
Vehicle details
- Year
- 2017
- Mileage
- 100,000 km
- Fuel
- Diesel
- Transmission
- Automatic
- Colour
- Brown
- Seller
- Naas Road Autos (Dealer)
- Location
- Dublin
◱
Market intelligence
Asking price€17,950
Estimated fair value€18,700
Fair range€17,000 – €19,800
Market confidence74/100
Comparable listings6
Data checkNo issues found
↓ 4.0% below comparable cars
Fair value is an estimated transaction value derived from live asking prices. It is not a verified transaction price.
↗
↓ €1,000 (-5.3%)Price history
€18,950 → €17,950
12/9/202626/9/2026
Seller has already reduced the asking price.
Compared with the market
6 similar live listings · this car is cheaper than 5 of 6.
🟢72/100
BMW X1 · SDRIVE18D SDRIVE 18D SE 205 HT72 4DR AUTO
2017 · 53,911 km · Dublin
€16,950
€2,750 under market
DieselAutomaticPrivate
🟡50/100
BMW X1 · 2.0D X-DRIVE X-LINE EDITION 5DR AUTOMATIC // 1 OWNER FROM NEW // IMMACULATE COND
2019 · 120,000 km · Dublin
€20,950
€800 under market
DieselAutomaticDealer
🟡55/100
BMW X1 · 2.0D X-DRIVE X-LINE EDITION 5DR AUTOMATIC // 1 OWNER FROM NEW // IMMACULATE COND
2019 · 110,000 km · Dublin
€21,950
€1,600 under market
DieselAutomaticDealer
🟡53/100
BMW X1 · sDrive18i SE
2019 · 117,792 km · Waterford
€21,975
PetrolAutomaticDealer
🟠33/100
BMW X1 · BMW X1 20D, M-SPORT 19"ALLOYS FULLY LOADED WITH SPEC
2018 · 124,130 km · Clare
€22,900
DieselAutomaticDealer
🟡52/100
BMW 1 Series · 2.0 D Automatic, Reversing camera
2017 · 80,159 km · Limerick
€17,995
DieselAutomaticDealer